Discovering the Best Immediate and Deferred Annuity Rates in 2023

Rectangle 11 (2)

Introduction

When planning for retirement, it’s essential to explore all available options, including immediate and deferred annuities. These annuity types offer different benefits depending on your financial goals and timeline. In this article, we’ll guide you through the process of finding the best immediate and deferred annuity rates and provide a list of the top rates available.

Understanding Immediate and Deferred Annuities

Before discussing the best rates, let’s clarify the differences between immediate and deferred annuities:

  1. Immediate annuities: With an immediate annuity, you make a lump-sum payment to an insurance company, and in return, they provide you with a guaranteed stream of income for a predetermined period or for life. Payouts begin shortly after the initial investment, usually within a year.
  2. Deferred annuities: Deferred annuities accumulate interest on your initial investment over time, with payouts beginning at a later date, such as 5, 10, or 20 years in the future. This delay allows your investment to grow, potentially resulting in higher payouts when the annuity’s income phase begins.

Immediate Annuities

Immediate annuities (Such as Single Premium Immediate Annuities) provide a guaranteed income stream that begins shortly after the purchase, usually within one year. Factors affecting immediate annuity rates include:

 

  1. Age and gender: The older the annuitant and the shorter their life expectancy, the higher the annuity rate. Gender also plays a role, as women tend to live longer than men, which can affect the payout rates.
  2. Policy type: The policy type, either joint or single, has a significant impact on the payouts of immediate and deferred annuities. In a joint policy, where two people receive payments until the last surviving spouse dies, the payouts are generally lower than in a single policy, where only one person receives payments. This is because the insurance company has to take into account the possibility of making payments for a longer period in a joint policy.
  3. Interest rates: Current interest rates in the market will impact immediate annuity rates. Higher market interest rates usually translate to higher annuity payout rates.

Advantages

  • Guaranteed income stream: Immediate annuities provide a secure income stream that lasts for the annuitant’s lifetime or a specified period.
  • Quick income generation: Payments begin shortly after the purchase, making immediate annuities ideal for those who need income right away.
  • Various payout options: Immediate annuities offer a range of payout options, allowing annuitants to tailor the income stream to their needs.

Disadvantages

  • Lack of liquidity: Once purchased, immediate annuities typically cannot be reversed, limiting access to the principal investment.
  • Inflation risk: The fixed income stream can lose purchasing power over time due to inflation, especially if no cost-of-living adjustments are included.
  • Limited growth potential: Immediate annuities provide a stable income but do not offer the potential for significant growth compared to other investment options.

Strategies for finding the best immediate and deferred annuity rates:

  • Compare payout rates from multiple insurance companies, taking into account the financial strength of each issuer.
  • Assess your financial needs and choose the payout option that best aligns with your goals. Consider the various payout options, such as single-life, joint-life, or period-certain annuities, to find the best fit for your needs.
  • Keep an eye on interest rates in the market and consider purchasing an immediate annuity when rates are higher to lock in a higher payout rate.
  • Assess surrender charges and fees: Review any surrender charges, administrative fees, or other costs associated with the annuity contract.
  • Check financial ratings: Examine the financial strength and credit ratings of the insurance company offering the annuity to ensure they are reputable and stable.

Best Immediate Annuity Rates (Updated as of April  2023)

Unlike fixed annuities and Multi-Year Guaranteed Annuities (MYGAs), which offer predetermined and uniform interest rates for all investors, the rates in immediate annuities are not the same for everyone. Instead, they depend upon several factors that can significantly impact the amount of income an individual receives. These factors include the current interest rate environment, the age and gender of the annuitant, the chosen payout option, and the specific insurance company offering the annuity. This variability in immediate annuity rates highlights the importance of considering one’s unique circumstances and financial goals when selecting an annuity product. It also emphasizes the need to shop around, compare quotes from different insurance companies, and stay informed about market conditions to secure the most favorable rates and terms for one’s specific situation.

Through this article, we will try to find out the best immediate annuity rates by comparing the monthly payout offered by different companies based on two different scenarios and payout options.

Scenario 1a – Policy Type: Single

Age: 60, Male

Payout Start: After 12 months

Premium: $100,000

Funding: Non-IRA (Non-Qualified)

Annuity Company

Monthly Income

Annual Income

Annual Payout Rate

Penn Mutual Life Insurance

$606

$7,272

7.27%

New York Life Insurance

$581

$6,972

6.97%

Jackson National Life Insurance

$577

$6,924

6.92%

Nationwide Life Insurance

$576

$6,912

6.91%

Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance

$570

$6,840

6.84%

Minnesota Life Insurance

$569

$6,828

6.83%

AIG

$567

$6,804

6.81%

Pacific Life Insurance

$566

$6,792

6.79%

United of Omaha Insurance

$565

$6,780

6.78%

Symetra Life Insurance

$560

$6,720

6.72%

Exhibit 1: Top Immediate Annuity Rates for hypothetical single applicant (as per Scenario 1a)  as of April 2023

Scenario 1b – Policy Type: Joint

Age
Primary – 60, Male
Joint – 55, Female

Payout Start: After 12 months

Premium: $100,000

Funding: Non-IRA (Non-Qualified)

Annuity Company

Monthly Income

Annual Income

Annual Payout Rate

Penn Mutual Life Insurance

$506

$6,072

6.07%

New York Life Insurance

$504

$6,048

6.04%

AIG

$501

$6,012

6.01%

Nationwide Life Insurance

$496

$5,952

5.95%

Pacific Life Insurance

$486

$5,832

5.83%

Jackson National Life Insurance

$485

$5,820

5.82%

Symetra Life Insurance

$484

$5,808

5.81%

Brighthouse Financial

$481

$5,772

5.77%

Integrity Life Insurance

$477

$5,724

5.72%

United of Omaha Insurance

$475

$5,700

5.70%

Exhibit 2: Top Immediate Annuity Rates for hypothetical joint applicant (as per Scenario 1b) as of April 2023

Notice how payout rate changes when the type of policy is joint, when compared to single. In a joint policy, the company’s expected payout is for a longer term when compared to a single policy. Also, notice how for best rates for immediate annuities differ as the policy type differs. It signifies that the SPIA rates truly differ based on factors like age, gender, policy type, payout type, etc. It is a good idea to shop around and compare rates from different companies to find the best deal for your needs. I recommend consulting a trusted financial professional to help you get the best SPIA as per your unique needs.

Note* – Please note that these rates are subject to change, and it’s essential to verify current rates and terms with the respective insurance providers. Also, keep in mind that the following annuities may have different features, surrender periods, and riders, so compare them based on your specific needs.

Deferred Income Annuities

A Deferred Income Annuity, like an immediate annuity, provides a guaranteed income stream, but the payments begin after some waiting period (known as a deferral period). The deferral period can range from a few years to several decades, depending on the terms of the contract.

As for the best deferred annuity rates, they vary depending on factors such as the insurance company, the type of annuity product, the length of the deferral period, and current interest rates.

Through this article, we will try to find out the best deferred annuity rates by comparing the monthly payout offered by different companies based on two different scenarios and payout options.

Scenario 2a – Policy Type: Single

Age: 60, Male

Payout Start: After 10 Years

Premium: $100,000

Funding: Non-IRA (Non-Qualified)

Annuity Company

Monthly Income

Annual Income

Annual Payout Rate

Symetra Life Insurance

$1,226

$14,712

14.71%

Brighthouse Financial

$1,205

$14,460

14.46%

United of Omaha Insurance

$1,147

$13,764

13.76%

Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance

$1,134

$13,608

13.61%

Guardian Insurance

$1,117

$13,404

13.40%

New York Life Insurance

$1,114

$13,368

13.37%

Global Atlantic

$1,106

$13,272

13.27%

Lincoln National Life Insurance

$1,092

$13,104

13.10%

Integrity Life Insurance

$1,082

$12,984

12.98%

AIG

$1,075

$12,900

12.90%

Exhibit 3: Top Deferred Annuity Rates for hypothetical single applicant (as per Scenario 2a) as of April 2023

Scenario 2b – Policy Type: Joint

Age
Primary – 60, Male
Joint – 55, Female

Payout Start: After 12 months

Premium: $100,000

Funding: Non-IRA (Non-Qualified)

Annuity Company

Monthly Income

Annual Income

Annual Payout Rate

Brighthouse Financial

$905

$10,860

10.86%

New York Life Insurance

$848

$10,176

10.18%

United of Omaha Insurance

$848

$10,176

10.18%

Symetra Life Insurance

$844

$10,128

10.13%

Guardian Insurance

$835

$10,020

10.02%

Global Atlantic

$834

$10,008

10.01%

AIG

$823

$9,876

9.88%

Integrity Life Insurance

$804

$9,648

9.65%

Lincoln National Life Insurance

$799

$9,588

9.59%

Exhibit 4: Top Deferred Annuity Rates for hypothetical joint applicant (as per Scenario 2b) as of April 2023

You’ll notice that there is a huge difference between payout rates of immediate annuities and deferred annuities. Deferred annuities have a waiting period, known as the deferral period before the annuity starts to pay out income. This period can range from a few years to several decades. During this time, the insurance company invests the premium, which allows it to grow tax-deferred. As a result, the payout rates for deferred annuities are generally higher than for immediate annuities.

Also, notice how for best rates for deferred annuities differ as the policy type differs. It signifies that the deferred rates truly differ based on factors like age, gender, policy type, payout type, etc. It is a good idea to shop around and compare rates from different companies to find the best deal for your needs. I recommend consulting a trusted financial professional to help you get the deferred annuity as per your unique needs.

Note* – Please note that these rates are subject to change, and it’s essential to verify current rates and terms with the respective insurance providers. Also, keep in mind that the following annuities may have different features, surrender periods, and riders, so compare them based on your specific needs.

Conclusion

By carefully researching and comparing immediate and deferred annuities, you can find the best rates and terms for your retirement needs. Remember to consider factors such as your financial goals, payout options, and insurance company ratings when making your decision. With the right annuity, you can enjoy a secure income stream during your retirement years and achieve financial peace of mind.